QRTP and ARM

Hi,

According to a recent investigation published in Electronic
Internationnal, ARM core processors are present in 76.8% of embedded
systems (against 57.8% in 1999!) - 539 Millions of core selled, MIPS
10.9%, Hitachi SH 7.2%, PowerPC
3%, others (including x86) 2.1%.
Ok, they don’t tell how many selled core are equiped with MMU!
But, according to a ARM data sheet, on 45 existing ARM processors, 20
own a MMU.

So actually, qrtp cannot aspire, with all your effort to support more
than 50 processors (today), to more than 16% of embedded market!
Strange for an embedded capable OS!

What about the others 76,8%?

Today, more 20 RTOS run on ARM and of course your main rivals are there!

Why not you?

Alain.

Alain Bonnefoy (alain.bonnefoy@icbt.com) wrote:

--------------6142F13CC9A2B33BCB96E30F
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit



Hi,

According to a recent investigation published in Electronic
Internationnal, ARM core processors are present in 76.8% of embedded
systems (against 57.8% in 1999!) - 539 Millions of core selled, MIPS
10.9%, Hitachi SH 7.2%, PowerPC
3%, others (including x86) 2.1%.
Ok, they don’t tell how many selled core are equiped with MMU!
But, according to a ARM data sheet, on 45 existing ARM processors, 20
own a MMU.

So actually, qrtp cannot aspire, with all your effort to support more
than 50 processors (today), to more than 16% of embedded market!
Strange for an embedded capable OS!

What about the others 76,8%?

Today, more 20 RTOS run on ARM and of course your main rivals are there!

Why not you?

Alain.

See:
www.qnx.com/news/tpnews/may10_00-armpowered.html

Be careful with these sorts of statistics as they can be very misleading
unless they specifically also breakdown 8, 16 and 32 bit processors and
microcontrollers. With respect to ARM, many of the ARM cores used in
high volume devices do not have an MMU (e.g. ARM 7). However, we
are seeing more of these devices planning use of ARM cores with MMUs
(e.g. ARM 720, ARM 920, etc). This is where QNX will paly very well.

QNX has and will release support for x86, PowerPC, MIPS, ARM/StrongARM
and SH4 (all with MMUs of course) :wink:

Your point is well taken.

Thanks

Grant

Alain Bonnefoy <alain.bonnefoy@icbt.com> wrote:

So actually, qrtp cannot aspire, with all your effort to support more
than 50 processors (today), to more than 16% of embedded market!

Strange for an embedded capable OS!

What about the others 76,8%?

Today, more 20 RTOS run on ARM and of course your main rivals are there!

Why not you?

Go to our website, and in the little box that says search', type ARM’
and hit enter.

I think you need to be careful with such statistics, because it all depends on just what you mean by an “embedded system”. If you simply mean some kind of device with a microprocessor inside it, you’ll find that the vast majority contain 8-bit and 4-bit processors, most of them with no OS of any kind. Clearly the article you refer to targeted some sub-set of embedded systems. It would be well to know just what sub-set they used.

Regards,

Bert Menkveld
Engineer
Corman Technologies Inc.

“Alain Bonnefoy” <alain.bonnefoy@icbt.com> wrote in message news:3A9CCDC8.E912EA24@icbt.com

Hi,
According to a recent investigation published in Electronic
Internationnal, ARM core processors are present in 76.8% of embedded
systems (against 57.8% in 1999!) - 539 Millions of core selled, MIPS 10.9%, Hitachi SH 7.2%, PowerPC
3%, others (including x86) 2.1%.
Ok, they don’t tell how many selled core are equiped with MMU!
But, according to a ARM data sheet, on 45 existing ARM processors, 20 own a MMU.

So actually, qrtp cannot aspire, with all your effort to support more
than 50 processors (today), to more than 16% of embedded market!
Strange for an embedded capable OS!

What about the others 76,8%?

Today, more 20 RTOS run on ARM and of course your main rivals are there!
Why not you?

Alain.

pete@qnx.com a écrit :

Alain Bonnefoy <> alain.bonnefoy@icbt.com> > wrote:

So actually, qrtp cannot aspire, with all your effort to support more
than 50 processors (today), to more than 16% of embedded market!

Strange for an embedded capable OS!

What about the others 76,8%?

Today, more 20 RTOS run on ARM and of course your main rivals are there!

Why not you?

Go to our website, and in the little box that says search', type ARM’
and hit enter.

Ok,
I was thinking that
http://qdn.qnx.com/support/hardware/platform/processors.html was up to date.
It should be!

Thanks,
Alain.

Alain Bonnefoy <alain.bonnefoy@icbt.com> wrote:

pete@qnx.com > a écrit :

Alain Bonnefoy <> alain.bonnefoy@icbt.com> > wrote:

So actually, qrtp cannot aspire, with all your effort to support more
than 50 processors (today), to more than 16% of embedded market!

Strange for an embedded capable OS!

What about the others 76,8%?

Today, more 20 RTOS run on ARM and of course your main rivals are there!

Why not you?

Go to our website, and in the little box that says search', type ARM’
and hit enter.

Ok,
I was thinking that
http://qdn.qnx.com/support/hardware/platform/processors.html > was up to date.
It should be!

We will get right on that…

Thanks,
Chris

Thanks,
Alain.

Chris Travis wrote:

Alain Bonnefoy <> alain.bonnefoy@icbt.com> > wrote:
pete@qnx.com > a écrit :

Alain Bonnefoy <> alain.bonnefoy@icbt.com> > wrote:

So actually, qrtp cannot aspire, with all your effort to support more
than 50 processors (today), to more than 16% of embedded market!

Strange for an embedded capable OS!

What about the others 76,8%?

Today, more 20 RTOS run on ARM and of course your main rivals are there!

Why not you?

Go to our website, and in the little box that says search', type ARM’
and hit enter.

Ok,
I was thinking that
http://qdn.qnx.com/support/hardware/platform/processors.html > was up to date.
It should be!

We will get right on that…

Just don’t forget to actually make it available when you add it to
supported list :wink:
Apparently you have ARM and SH support for a while, but it never was
available either for free or for money, not even as beta to the best of
my knowledge.

  • igor