Commercial update 6.1 -> 6.2 only as bundle with support??

Hi all,

just I talked with a QNX 6.1 customer and asked him to update to 6.2
Hmm, he told me that it’s too expensive for his small company …

After the engineer did a good job to convience his boss to switch from
Linux to QNX6 they have bought the commercial version of QNX 6.1 (RTP)
incl. some Runtimes.

Recently he asked his QNX sales for an update to QNX 6.2 and he was
told that the update is only available as bundle with support for
~ $1,200US (exchanged amount from his currency)

He doesn’t need direct support from his QNX sales and is going to stay
with QNX 6.1 now. His boss is a little bit upset about hidden costs,
so it becomes harder to justify QNX for next projects :frowning:

Are update bundles a new QSSL stragedy or is it a single case??
[It’s our first customer with this strange experience ]

Jutta

P.S.
That customer is very happy with Rob’s Neutrino book and the only
“update bundle” he would accept has to come with the video trainig
from Rob. … anyone listening from QSSL-Sales ?? :wink:

Jutta Steinhoff <j-steinhoff@web.de> wrote:

Recently he asked his QNX sales for an update to QNX 6.2 and he was
told that the update is only available as bundle with support for
~ $1,200US (exchanged amount from his currency)

I’ve heard rumors of this, and it’s been my suspicion for a while. At
some point (and this included 6.1) the policy on updates changed. The
only way to obtain them is by purchasing a support plan, although I am
a bit confused as to how that works (since all the updates for 6.1 were
publically available).

I’m in a similiar situation, where I have a NTO 1.0 dev seat, which I was
told qualifies as an RTP/6.1 dev seat, but how I actually make that into
a 6.2 SE dev seat, I have no idea.

It is a bit distressing that a company that has NEVER charged for updates
is now suddenly doing so.

Cheers,
Camz.

It bothers me that for a year and a half QSSL has been promising bug fixes
to 6.0.1C. They never appeared. Instead there is a new version 6.2. This
fellow has actually paid for 6.1 and can’t get his bug fixes. That sucks.

<camz@passageway.com> wrote in message news:ai6jl6$dsb$1@inn.qnx.com

Jutta Steinhoff <> j-steinhoff@web.de> > wrote:
Recently he asked his QNX sales for an update to QNX 6.2 and he was
told that the update is only available as bundle with support for
~ $1,200US (exchanged amount from his currency)

I’ve heard rumors of this, and it’s been my suspicion for a while. At
some point (and this included 6.1) the policy on updates changed. The
only way to obtain them is by purchasing a support plan, although I am
a bit confused as to how that works (since all the updates for 6.1 were
publically available).

I’m in a similiar situation, where I have a NTO 1.0 dev seat, which I was
told qualifies as an RTP/6.1 dev seat, but how I actually make that into
a 6.2 SE dev seat, I have no idea.

It is a bit distressing that a company that has NEVER charged for updates
is now suddenly doing so.

Cheers,
Camz.

camz@passageway.com wrote:

It is a bit distressing that a company that has NEVER charged for updates
is now suddenly doing so.

It is NOT true that QNX has never charged for updates.

4.1x → 4.20
4.2[0-2] → 4.23

Watcom 8.x → 9.x
(I think, maybe, also Watcom 9.x → 10.x)

Also, it is my understanding that we have as a general policy
charged for upgrades to run-time systems (anything volume
licensed).

There have also been at least attempts with QNX4 to include
upgrades/fixes as part of support plans – rather than allowing
them for free. This is not a new thing.

-David

QNX Training Services
http://www.qnx.com/support/training/
Please followup in this newsgroup if you have further questions.

camz@passageway.com wrote:

Jutta Steinhoff <> j-steinhoff@web.de> > wrote:
Recently he asked his QNX sales for an update to QNX 6.2 and he was
told that the update is only available as bundle with support for
~ $1,200US (exchanged amount from his currency)

I’ve heard rumors of this, and it’s been my suspicion for a while. At
some point (and this included 6.1) the policy on updates changed. The
only way to obtain them is by purchasing a support plan,

Notice, our customer made bad exerience with his local QNX support as he
told me, so it’s even harder to accept paying money for something which
has definitely no value for him !

In general, the QNX4 disk and QNX-RTP CD made QNX more known and it is
generating commercial customers now :slight_smile: An important marketing
argument for QNX was compatibility of older and new versions was well as
downloading updates (not upgrades) free of charge.

The update policy from M$ with unpredictable costs for the future let
also grow the Linux community for industrial use. Now QSSL wants to
“fish” in the Linux pool. Charging for QNX 6.2 updates by bundling with
support plans leads to a deterrent effect…

BTW, in EU countries such update/support bundles could be seen as fraud
in equity. When there are 2 separate products, one with a price and one
free of charge like the update, so both have to be available separately,
too. If not, no problem to take legal steps.


When a customer pays $4K or $8K for a QNX6 developer’s seat I would
expect that bug fixes are included. For a quite new addition an “upgrade
price” is ok!


although I am
a bit confused as to how that works (since all the updates for 6.1 were
publically available).

I’m in a similiar situation, where I have a NTO 1.0 dev seat,

that’s very old, NTO 2.0 was a quite new version, so upgrades were not
free of charge when I remember right.

which I was
told qualifies as an RTP/6.1 dev seat, but how I actually make that into
a 6.2 SE dev seat, I have no idea.

I never heard about NTO 1.0 or 2.0 updates to RTP/6.1

It is a bit distressing that a company that has NEVER charged for updates
is now suddenly doing so.

When I understood our customer correctly, so the update is still free of
charge but no way to get it separately. So you will get the update as
“add on” for ordering support… that’s really strange :frowning:

Jutta

Jutta Steinhoff <j-steinhoff@web.de> wrote:

Hi all,

just I talked with a QNX 6.1 customer and asked him to update to 6.2
Hmm, he told me that it’s too expensive for his small company …

After the engineer did a good job to convience his boss to switch from
Linux to QNX6 they have bought the commercial version of QNX 6.1 (RTP)
incl. some Runtimes.

Recently he asked his QNX sales for an update to QNX 6.2 and he was
told that the update is only available as bundle with support for
~ $1,200US (exchanged amount from his currency)

He doesn’t need direct support from his QNX sales and is going to stay
with QNX 6.1 now. His boss is a little bit upset about hidden costs,
so it becomes harder to justify QNX for next projects > :frowning:

Are update bundles a new QSSL stragedy or is it a single case??
[It’s our first customer with this strange experience ]

Jutta

P.S.
That customer is very happy with Rob’s Neutrino book and the only
“update bundle” he would accept has to come with the video trainig
from Rob. … anyone listening from QSSL-Sales ?? > :wink:

Works for me! :slight_smile:

Thank you for that, Jutta!

Cheers,
-RK


Robert Krten, PARSE Software Devices +1 613 599 8316.
Realtime Systems Architecture, Books, Video-based and Instructor-led
Training and Consulting at www.parse.com.
Email my initials at parse dot com.

David Gibbs wrote:

camz@passageway.com > wrote:

It is a bit distressing that a company that has NEVER charged for updates
is now suddenly doing so.

It is NOT true that QNX has never charged for updates.

4.1x → 4.20
4.2[0-2] → 4.23

Watcom 8.x → 9.x
(I think, maybe, also Watcom 9.x → 10.x)

Also, it is my understanding that we have as a general policy
charged for upgrades to run-time systems (anything volume

AFAIK, that policy is only some years old. Customers have to pay a
higher amount for runtime systems with an upgrade option, even when not
knowing if they will ever use. We had some discussions in Germany
because of companies wanted not to pay the upgrade fee before really
upgrading…

There have also been at least attempts with QNX4 to include
upgrades/fixes as part of support plans – rather than allowing
them for free. This is not a new thing.

It’s interesting that you talk about “attempts”. It’s up to QSSL to make
a price for something. It’s strange to charge through the backdoor and
give updates as add ons. Every company which is legally working with QNX
should be able to order updates and upgrades on direct way when there is
to pay for. Indirect payment will not be accepted from many customers
and leaves a nasty taste…

BTW, it should also be the interest of QSSL that their customers are
working with the newest version

  • Jutta


-David

QNX Training Services
http://www.qnx.com/support/training/
Please followup in this newsgroup if you have further questions.

Robert Krten wrote:

Jutta Steinhoff <> j-steinhoff@web.de> > wrote:

[clip…]

P.S.
That customer is very happy with Rob’s Neutrino book and the only
“update bundle” he would accept has to come with the video trainig
from Rob. … anyone listening from QSSL-Sales ?? > :wink:

Works for me! > :slight_smile:

:slight_smile: Keep up your good work !

Thank you for that, Jutta!

Rob, we are happy to save time for support and our customers get started
much faster. May be I should ask for written comments at next, so I can
pass it to you :wink:

Cheers,
Jutta

“David Gibbs” <dagibbs@qnx.com> wrote in message
news:ai70bp$o3e$1@nntp.qnx.com

There have also been at least attempts with QNX4 to include
upgrades/fixes as part of support plans – rather than allowing
them for free. This is not a new thing.

-David

For the most part this is not true. Many, many bug fix updates were posted
to QUICS and provided for free. Only significantly enhanced products have
been given a new version number and there been a charge to upgrade.

I.E. In my opinion, TCP/IP V 5.0 is a much better product than 4.xx. It is
a completely redesigned IP engine. But there was no charge to upgrade.
There also has never been a lot of fanfare that it even existed.

Jutta Steinhoff <j-steinhoff@web.de> wrote:

[snip]

Recently he asked his QNX sales for an update to QNX 6.2 and he was
told that the update is only available as bundle with support for
~ $1,200US (exchanged amount from his currency)

He doesn’t need direct support from his QNX sales and is going to stay
with QNX 6.1 now. His boss is a little bit upset about hidden costs,
so it becomes harder to justify QNX for next projects > :frowning:

Are update bundles a new QSSL stragedy or is it a single case??
[It’s our first customer with this strange experience ]

[snip]

QSSL can charge whatever they like for the upgrade, that’s a business
and marketing decision that they make – everyone can certainly put
in their opinions (and I’m sure will), but that’s not my concern here.

My concern is with the aspect of bundling support with the upgrade.

This can be viewed as anti-competetive to, say, third parties
that are providing contract customer support. Effectively, it says that
when you upgrade, you’re implicitly killing off the business of third
party support providers. Sure, there are factions within QSSL (and indeed
any company) that view this as a good thing, but the vast majority of
people there are not so narrow-minded – I won’t belabour the point about
why third-parties are a “good thing”, it’s been done to death.

Anyway, IF this is indeed the case, (I don’t think anyone from QSSL has yet
actually officially confirmed this as 100%) then there is serious cause for
concern. Not only from a legal perspective for QSSL (i.e., getting sued
for bundling or monopolistic practices or whatever, which varies by country
and I’m not a lawyer), but for the third parties.

Just raising the ugly spectre before it gets buried :slight_smile:

Cheers,
-RK


Robert Krten, PARSE Software Devices +1 613 599 8316.
Realtime Systems Architecture, Books, Video-based and Instructor-led
Training and Consulting at www.parse.com.
Email my initials at parse dot com.

Robert Krten wrote:

Jutta Steinhoff <> j-steinhoff@web.de> > wrote:

[snip]

Recently he asked his QNX sales for an update to QNX 6.2 and he was
told that the update is only available as bundle with support for
~ $1,200US (exchanged amount from his currency)

He doesn’t need direct support from his QNX sales and is going to stay
with QNX 6.1 now. His boss is a little bit upset about hidden costs,
so it becomes harder to justify QNX for next projects > :frowning:

Are update bundles a new QSSL stragedy or is it a single case??
[It’s our first customer with this strange experience ]

[snip]

QSSL can charge whatever they like for the upgrade, that’s a business
and marketing decision that they make – everyone can certainly put
in their opinions (and I’m sure will), but that’s not my concern here.

My concern is with the aspect of bundling support with the upgrade.

That’s the point. If a customer has already a negative opinion about the
support of e.g. a local subsidiary … he will feel to be scrowed up to
buy something useless and this will kill the approach to continue the
usage of QNX.

IMHO … no one has problem to pay for upgrades (if they are one …) …
but it should still the decision of the customer what he is buying or
not.

Cheers

Armin



This can be viewed as anti-competetive to, say, third parties
that are providing contract customer support. Effectively, it says that
when you upgrade, you’re implicitly killing off the business of third
party support providers. Sure, there are factions within QSSL (and indeed
any company) that view this as a good thing, but the vast majority of
people there are not so narrow-minded – I won’t belabour the point about
why third-parties are a “good thing”, it’s been done to death.

Anyway, IF this is indeed the case, (I don’t think anyone from QSSL has yet
actually officially confirmed this as 100%) then there is serious cause for
concern. Not only from a legal perspective for QSSL (i.e., getting sued
for bundling or monopolistic practices or whatever, which varies by country
and I’m not a lawyer), but for the third parties.

Just raising the ugly spectre before it gets buried > :slight_smile:

Cheers,
-RK


Robert Krten, PARSE Software Devices +1 613 599 8316.
Realtime Systems Architecture, Books, Video-based and Instructor-led
Training and Consulting at > www.parse.com> .
Email my initials at parse dot com.

Armin Steinhoff wrote:

Robert Krten wrote:

Jutta Steinhoff <> j-steinhoff@web.de> > wrote:

[snip]

Recently he asked his QNX sales for an update to QNX 6.2 and he was
told that the update is only available as bundle with support for
~ $1,200US (exchanged amount from his currency)

He doesn’t need direct support from his QNX sales and is going to stay
with QNX 6.1 now. His boss is a little bit upset about hidden costs,
so it becomes harder to justify QNX for next projects > :frowning:

Are update bundles a new QSSL stragedy or is it a single case??
[It’s our first customer with this strange experience ]

[snip]

QSSL can charge whatever they like for the upgrade, that’s a business
and marketing decision that they make – everyone can certainly put
in their opinions (and I’m sure will), but that’s not my concern here.

My concern is with the aspect of bundling support with the upgrade.

That’s the point. If a customer has already a negative opinion about the
support of e.g. a local subsidiary … he will feel to be scrowed up to
buy something useless and this will kill the approach to continue the
usage of QNX.

What’s the problem to give QNX users a free choice where to order
support … and it’s up to QSSx and their distributors to try to
convience with quality in support… and not to force customers to
accept support contracts as necessary evil in order to get update
options, updates etc.

I’m really amazed about actual information from customers about
their QNX6 sales experience. Companies which bought already QNX RTP
for prototyping have bad luck now when updating to QNX6.2
Companies which were penny-pinching are even rewarded now: they
used legally the n/c RTP version for their prototypes and could buy
Momentics w/o update support bundle… and should be delighted,
BUT when a customer wants only the SE version and asks how to upgrade
later to PE, so he has to sign a support contract for getting that
option. A customer was really angry to have no upgrade rights from
SE to PE when not signing for support :frowning: That customer is not very
happy with his local QNX support but signing was the only possibility
to get later the “rest” for PE to the difference of price…

Hello QSSL Sales if listening, please check your nice “support bundle
policy” and don’t charge customers for anything they don’t want or
don’t need. Please try to charge for stuff what the customers want
and get! If you feel that your updates cost money so don’t charge
support instead.

  • Jutta

Like most organizations, our Standard Support and Maintenance Program
ensures that customers have access to updates/upgrades as they are released.
Please be assured that this program is not mandatory. However, in order to
ensure that our customers receive the best customer service and
satisfaction, we encourage the purchase of this plan so that customers get
the full benefit of all the features included in the program -
patches/updates/upgrades, technical support, and access to support and R&D
resources through a semi-private newgroup qdn.private.standard - all of
which are not be available to those without plans.

Keep in mind that there has always been a charge to upgrade to a major
release; this program now includes this fee, which is 25% of the list price
of the product purchased. This type of maintenance fee is a common business
practice as it tells the customer buying support that there is value in it,
in particular the technology available in the updates.

This program is particularly beneficial for customers who would like to
upgrade from QNX v6.x to QNX Momentics SE. By purchasing standard support
plan, they get the upgrade (and future upgrades) for no charge, and also
provides them with access to Standard technical support for the year.

Debbie Kane

“Jutta Steinhoff” <j-steinhoff@web.de> wrote in message
news:3D46CC0D.19B0FED3@web.de

Hi all,

just I talked with a QNX 6.1 customer and asked him to update to 6.2
Hmm, he told me that it’s too expensive for his small company …

After the engineer did a good job to convience his boss to switch from
Linux to QNX6 they have bought the commercial version of QNX 6.1 (RTP)
incl. some Runtimes.

Recently he asked his QNX sales for an update to QNX 6.2 and he was
told that the update is only available as bundle with support for
~ $1,200US (exchanged amount from his currency)

He doesn’t need direct support from his QNX sales and is going to stay
with QNX 6.1 now. His boss is a little bit upset about hidden costs,
so it becomes harder to justify QNX for next projects > :frowning:

Are update bundles a new QSSL stragedy or is it a single case??
[It’s our first customer with this strange experience ]

Jutta

P.S.
That customer is very happy with Rob’s Neutrino book and the only
“update bundle” he would accept has to come with the video trainig
from Rob. … anyone listening from QSSL-Sales ?? > :wink:

Where does that leave people who purchased 6.0.1 and were told for the last
18 months, “Oh, that will be fixed in the next release”?

“Debbie Kane” <debbie@qnx.com> wrote in message
news:aibfkg$4ss$1@inn.qnx.com

Like most organizations, our Standard Support and Maintenance Program
ensures that customers have access to updates/upgrades as they are
released.
Please be assured that this program is not mandatory. However, in order to
ensure that our customers receive the best customer service and
satisfaction, we encourage the purchase of this plan so that customers get
the full benefit of all the features included in the program -
patches/updates/upgrades, technical support, and access to support and R&D
resources through a semi-private newgroup qdn.private.standard - all of
which are not be available to those without plans.

Keep in mind that there has always been a charge to upgrade to a major
release; this program now includes this fee, which is 25% of the list
price
of the product purchased. This type of maintenance fee is a common
business
practice as it tells the customer buying support that there is value in
it,
in particular the technology available in the updates.

This program is particularly beneficial for customers who would like to
upgrade from QNX v6.x to QNX Momentics SE. By purchasing standard support
plan, they get the upgrade (and future upgrades) for no charge, and also
provides them with access to Standard technical support for the year.

Debbie Kane

“Jutta Steinhoff” <> j-steinhoff@web.de> > wrote in message
news:> 3D46CC0D.19B0FED3@web.de> …
Hi all,

just I talked with a QNX 6.1 customer and asked him to update to 6.2
Hmm, he told me that it’s too expensive for his small company …

After the engineer did a good job to convience his boss to switch from
Linux to QNX6 they have bought the commercial version of QNX 6.1 (RTP)
incl. some Runtimes.

Recently he asked his QNX sales for an update to QNX 6.2 and he was
told that the update is only available as bundle with support for
~ $1,200US (exchanged amount from his currency)

He doesn’t need direct support from his QNX sales and is going to stay
with QNX 6.1 now. His boss is a little bit upset about hidden costs,
so it becomes harder to justify QNX for next projects > :frowning:

Are update bundles a new QSSL stragedy or is it a single case??
[It’s our first customer with this strange experience ]

Jutta

P.S.
That customer is very happy with Rob’s Neutrino book and the only
“update bundle” he would accept has to come with the video trainig
from Rob. … anyone listening from QSSL-Sales ?? > :wink:

Hi Bill,

Perhaps I don’t understand your question.
Is the question, can the support plan get you upgraded from 6.01 to 6.2,
then yes.
If it is…are the fixes you want in the latest product release? Not sure
that I can answer that…
I was responding to the issue of support and upgrades.

deb

“Bill Caroselli (Q-TPS)” <QTPS@EarthLink.net> wrote in message
news:aibhkf$63q$1@inn.qnx.com

Where does that leave people who purchased 6.0.1 and were told for the
last
18 months, “Oh, that will be fixed in the next release”?

“Debbie Kane” <> debbie@qnx.com> > wrote in message
news:aibfkg$4ss$> 1@inn.qnx.com> …
Like most organizations, our Standard Support and Maintenance Program
ensures that customers have access to updates/upgrades as they are
released.
Please be assured that this program is not mandatory. However, in order
to
ensure that our customers receive the best customer service and
satisfaction, we encourage the purchase of this plan so that customers
get
the full benefit of all the features included in the program -
patches/updates/upgrades, technical support, and access to support and
R&D
resources through a semi-private newgroup qdn.private.standard - all of
which are not be available to those without plans.

Keep in mind that there has always been a charge to upgrade to a major
release; this program now includes this fee, which is 25% of the list
price
of the product purchased. This type of maintenance fee is a common
business
practice as it tells the customer buying support that there is value in
it,
in particular the technology available in the updates.

This program is particularly beneficial for customers who would like to
upgrade from QNX v6.x to QNX Momentics SE. By purchasing standard
support
plan, they get the upgrade (and future upgrades) for no charge, and also
provides them with access to Standard technical support for the year.

Debbie Kane

“Jutta Steinhoff” <> j-steinhoff@web.de> > wrote in message
news:> 3D46CC0D.19B0FED3@web.de> …
Hi all,

just I talked with a QNX 6.1 customer and asked him to update to 6.2
Hmm, he told me that it’s too expensive for his small company …

After the engineer did a good job to convience his boss to switch from
Linux to QNX6 they have bought the commercial version of QNX 6.1 (RTP)
incl. some Runtimes.

Recently he asked his QNX sales for an update to QNX 6.2 and he was
told that the update is only available as bundle with support for
~ $1,200US (exchanged amount from his currency)

He doesn’t need direct support from his QNX sales and is going to stay
with QNX 6.1 now. His boss is a little bit upset about hidden costs,
so it becomes harder to justify QNX for next projects > :frowning:

Are update bundles a new QSSL stragedy or is it a single case??
[It’s our first customer with this strange experience ]

Jutta

P.S.
That customer is very happy with Rob’s Neutrino book and the only
“update bundle” he would accept has to come with the video trainig
from Rob. … anyone listening from QSSL-Sales ?? > :wink:
\

Debbie,

you are talking about Standard Support and Maintenance Program.

When it’s a “Maintenance Program” it should have that name and should
also be listed in the price lists that customers know in advance what
are their total costs!

Did I understand correctly that customers who are interested in bug
fixes (updates) have to pay annually 25% of SE or PE as well as for
Runtimes ??

There is a difference between updates and upgrades and IMHO you should
offer bug fixes (updates) for free!

BTW, what kind of technical support (and from whom) is included with the
Maintenance program? Do you think technical support is beneficial for
companies which are already unsatisfied with their local QNX support ??

Does the semi-private newgroup qdn.private.standard belong to each
support offer which comes with a request for updates? I never heard
about from customers…

Isn’t it possible to separate Maintenance and Support Plans??

You wrote: “This program is particularly beneficial for customers who
would like to upgrade from QNX v6.x to QNX Momentics SE.”

Are you aware that many companies doing prototypes with the n/c RTP
version are saving money compared with companies which bought already
the RTP version for prototyping? Many companies are still in the
prototype phase, so they are punished now with the “update fee” because
of already buying RTP…

What is the reason for a support/maintenance program when a customer
buys SE and wants later the “rest” to PE for the price difference?

I see at our customer base that these foggy new QNX policies lead to
unsatisfaction and in some cases staying away from QNX in the future.
Customers don’t like financial surprises (often a main argument to look
for anything else but M$) so it would be great to get information about
the QNX maintenance policy before deciding for QNX.

BTW, who is staying with QNX for years is also surprised because of
there was never any anouncement about changed update policy.
In the last years for QNX4 was offered an additional fee of 25% to get
the option to update… and there was much trouble in Germany because of
nobody knows in advance if it makes sense to update a plant when it’s
running. Customers was told that there is no way to update some years
later when there is not payed the update fee in advance. So some
customers pay the additional fee although they never updated and will
probably not do in the future.

A very important marketing argument in the past was that QNX updates
(not upgrades!) are free of charge!

Don’t be surprised when QNX becomes less attractive for some companies
in the future.

  • Jutta



    Debbie Kane wrote:

Like most organizations, our Standard Support and Maintenance Program
ensures that customers have access to updates/upgrades as they are released.
Please be assured that this program is not mandatory. However, in order to
ensure that our customers receive the best customer service and
satisfaction, we encourage the purchase of this plan so that customers get
the full benefit of all the features included in the program -
patches/updates/upgrades, technical support, and access to support and R&D
resources through a semi-private newgroup qdn.private.standard - all of
which are not be available to those without plans.

Keep in mind that there has always been a charge to upgrade to a major
release; this program now includes this fee, which is 25% of the list price
of the product purchased. This type of maintenance fee is a common business
practice as it tells the customer buying support that there is value in it,
in particular the technology available in the updates.

This program is particularly beneficial for customers who would like to
upgrade from QNX v6.x to QNX Momentics SE. By purchasing standard support
plan, they get the upgrade (and future upgrades) for no charge, and also
provides them with access to Standard technical support for the year.

Debbie Kane

“Jutta Steinhoff” <> j-steinhoff@web.de> > wrote in message
news:> 3D46CC0D.19B0FED3@web.de> …
Hi all,

just I talked with a QNX 6.1 customer and asked him to update to 6.2
Hmm, he told me that it’s too expensive for his small company …

After the engineer did a good job to convience his boss to switch from
Linux to QNX6 they have bought the commercial version of QNX 6.1 (RTP)
incl. some Runtimes.

Recently he asked his QNX sales for an update to QNX 6.2 and he was
told that the update is only available as bundle with support for
~ $1,200US (exchanged amount from his currency)

He doesn’t need direct support from his QNX sales and is going to stay
with QNX 6.1 now. His boss is a little bit upset about hidden costs,
so it becomes harder to justify QNX for next projects > :frowning:

Are update bundles a new QSSL stragedy or is it a single case??
[It’s our first customer with this strange experience ]

Jutta

P.S.
That customer is very happy with Rob’s Neutrino book and the only
“update bundle” he would accept has to come with the video trainig
from Rob. … anyone listening from QSSL-Sales ?? > :wink:

QSSL is the only one that doesn’t.

“Debbie Kane” <debbie@qnx.com> wrote in message
news:aibkng$8he$1@inn.qnx.com

Hi Bill,

Perhaps I don’t understand your question.

“Bill Caroselli (Q-TPS)” <> QTPS@EarthLink.net> > wrote in message
news:aibhkf$63q$> 1@inn.qnx.com> …
Where does that leave people who purchased 6.0.1 and were told for
the last 18 months, “Oh, that will be fixed in the next release”?

“Jutta Steinhoff” <j-steinhoff@web.de> wrote in message
news:3D495E75.E62BF289@web.de

Debbie,

you are talking about Standard Support and Maintenance Program.

When it’s a “Maintenance Program” it should have that name and should
also be listed in the price lists that customers know in advance what
are their total costs!

I’m not sure what price list you are referring to, but I will notify

sales/marketing to ensure that it is listed on outgoing pricelists or
quotes. It is not our intent to ‘hide’ this cost.

Did I understand correctly that customers who are interested in bug
fixes (updates) have to pay annually 25% of SE or PE as well as for
Runtimes ??

This program is primarily for development seats.
Runtimes are covered under the customer’s specific OEM contract, and is
usually tied to a particular release of their product and version of the OS.
However, if the customer has the Standard Plan, they are capable of shipping
later versions of the software on ‘new’ versions of their product. Going
back and retrofitting systems in the field still requires a new OEM
contract.

There is a difference between updates and upgrades and IMHO you should
offer bug fixes (updates) for free!

Interim updates will continue to be no charge and downloadable.
Updates to newer versions (ie. 6.1 → 6.2) is covered under the S&M Plan.
Again, their used to be a fee to update, I believe it was 50% of the cost of
the new version. Now it is 25% of purchased product and includes technical
support, etc.

BTW, what kind of technical support (and from whom) is included with the
Maintenance program? Do you think technical support is beneficial for
companies which are already unsatisfied with their local QNX support ??

Customers can contact any QSS office they choose. Contact info is provided
in the Standard Support Plan User’s Guide at:
http://www.qnx.com/support/sd_techsupport/QNXstandardsupportplan.pdf

Does the semi-private newgroup qdn.private.standard belong to each
support offer which comes with a request for updates? I never heard
about from customers…

Again, this is documented in the User’s Guide and is available to all
Standard Support customers, they use their support plan access to get
through the authentication.
Listing of all newsgroups: http://www.qnx.com/support/sd_newsgroups.html

Isn’t it possible to separate Maintenance and Support Plans??

You wrote: “This program is particularly beneficial for customers who
would like to upgrade from QNX v6.x to QNX Momentics SE.”

Are you aware that many companies doing prototypes with the n/c RTP
version are saving money compared with companies which bought already
the RTP version for prototyping? Many companies are still in the
prototype phase, so they are punished now with the “update fee” because
of already buying RTP…

What is the reason for a support/maintenance program when a customer
buys SE and wants later the “rest” to PE for the price difference?

SE and PE are different products. It is not an upgrade from one product to
another.
However, I believe you are credited what you paid for SE when you choose to
move to PE.
The S&M Plan then allows you updates to that product line.

I see at our customer base that these foggy new QNX policies lead to
unsatisfaction and in some cases staying away from QNX in the future.
Customers don’t like financial surprises (often a main argument to look
for anything else but M$) so it would be great to get information about
the QNX maintenance policy before deciding for QNX.

This is unfortunate. I will inform the Sales team (NA and International)
that this may need more visibility on this.

BTW, who is staying with QNX for years is also surprised because of
there was never any anouncement about changed update policy.
In the last years for QNX4 was offered an additional fee of 25% to get
the option to update… and there was much trouble in Germany because of
nobody knows in advance if it makes sense to update a plant when it’s
running. Customers was told that there is no way to update some years
later when there is not payed the update fee in advance. So some
customers pay the additional fee although they never updated and will
probably not do in the future.

If a QNX4 customer wanted to upgrade to another version, they would have
always needed to pay an upgrade fee.
It is now called Standard Support and Maintenance Fee.


A very important marketing argument in the past was that QNX updates
(not upgrades!) are free of charge!

They are as they always have been.


Don’t be surprised when QNX becomes less attractive for some companies
in the future.

  • Jutta



    Debbie Kane wrote:

Like most organizations, our Standard Support and Maintenance Program
ensures that customers have access to updates/upgrades as they are
released.
Please be assured that this program is not mandatory. However, in order
to
ensure that our customers receive the best customer service and
satisfaction, we encourage the purchase of this plan so that customers
get
the full benefit of all the features included in the program -
patches/updates/upgrades, technical support, and access to support and
R&D
resources through a semi-private newgroup qdn.private.standard - all of
which are not be available to those without plans.

Keep in mind that there has always been a charge to upgrade to a major
release; this program now includes this fee, which is 25% of the list
price
of the product purchased. This type of maintenance fee is a common
business
practice as it tells the customer buying support that there is value in
it,
in particular the technology available in the updates.

This program is particularly beneficial for customers who would like to
upgrade from QNX v6.x to QNX Momentics SE. By purchasing standard
support
plan, they get the upgrade (and future upgrades) for no charge, and also
provides them with access to Standard technical support for the year.

Debbie Kane

“Jutta Steinhoff” <> j-steinhoff@web.de> > wrote in message
news:> 3D46CC0D.19B0FED3@web.de> …
Hi all,

just I talked with a QNX 6.1 customer and asked him to update to 6.2
Hmm, he told me that it’s too expensive for his small company …

After the engineer did a good job to convience his boss to switch from
Linux to QNX6 they have bought the commercial version of QNX 6.1 (RTP)
incl. some Runtimes.

Recently he asked his QNX sales for an update to QNX 6.2 and he was
told that the update is only available as bundle with support for
~ $1,200US (exchanged amount from his currency)

He doesn’t need direct support from his QNX sales and is going to stay
with QNX 6.1 now. His boss is a little bit upset about hidden costs,
so it becomes harder to justify QNX for next projects > :frowning:

Are update bundles a new QSSL stragedy or is it a single case??
[It’s our first customer with this strange experience ]

Jutta

P.S.
That customer is very happy with Rob’s Neutrino book and the only
“update bundle” he would accept has to come with the video trainig
from Rob. … anyone listening from QSSL-Sales ?? > :wink:

Jutta Steinhoff <j-steinhoff@web.de> wrote:

Don’t be surprised when QNX becomes less attractive for some companies
in the future.

I can confirm. We have dealt with QNX4 for many years. We were a little
bit carefull to buy QNX6.1 and now we are really glad that we were so late
a we have decided to stop dealing with QNX4/6 completely.

Andy

On Mon, 5 Aug 2002 06:56:55 +0000 (UTC), andy@microstep-mis.com wrote:

Jutta Steinhoff <> j-steinhoff@web.de> > wrote:

Don’t be surprised when QNX becomes less attractive for some companies
in the future.

I can confirm. We have dealt with QNX4 for many years. We were a little
bit carefull to buy QNX6.1 and now we are really glad that we were so late
a we have decided to stop dealing with QNX4/6 completely.

I think QNX is offering better value than before.

As I see it, QNX is in the process of transitioning
to a model where support and upgrades are a
significant revenue source, similar to their
competitors.

Long term, the goal is survival of the company
and product, which is in all our interest.

The current overlap of support&upgrades is just
a blip, and in my view, not a reason to discount QNX…
But then, YMMV